Whether it’s by the slice or in a cup, The Cheesecake Lady Indy is making waves with her delicious and innovative cheesecakes and cheesecake-like desserts. Originally known for her no-bake cheesecakes, fun mix-ins and crumbles, The Cheesecake Lady also makes baked cheesecakes, cookie sandwiches, cake slices and more — all with amazing flavor combinations.
Cheesecake Cups
One of the highlights of The Cheesecake Lady’s menu is her cheesecake cups. The Strawberry Crunch cheesecake is a customer favorite, but you’ll also find classics like cherry, banana pudding, cookies and cream, peach cobbler and peanut butter brownie. Cheesecake cups come in 4-ounce, 6-ounce, 12-ounce or 16-ounce cups, with prices ranging from $5.50 to $13.50. The one-pound cheesecake cup is definitely a treat-yourself deal, but one that you won’t regret!
Related Page: Little Foodies – Local Kid Favorites
Classic Cheesecakes
If you’re more into classic cheesecakes, The Cheesecake Lady accepts pre-orders for full cheesecakes. If you can’t decide which flavor of cheesecake to order, the perfect solution is the 13×9 cheesecake, which you can order in up to four flavors. This allows you to sample a variety of her creations and find your personal favorites.
How to Get Your Cheesecake Fix
You’ll find The Cheesecake Lady’s cozy cheesecake store in the Butler-Tarkington neighborhood of Indianapolis, just south of Butler University. You can also order your desserts through Doordash. One thing to keep in mind: The menu options rotate daily, and due to the popularity of their limited items, they can sell out fast.
The Cheesecake Lady is open Tuesday to Saturday from 12-6 p.m., and closed on Sundays and Mondays. To find out which flavors The Cheesecake Lady will be offering, check her social media pages or visit thecheesecakeladyindy.com.
