Little Foodies: The Cheesecake Lady

Whether it’s by the slice or in a cup, The Cheesecake Lady Indy is making waves with her delicious and innovative cheesecakes and cheesecake-like desserts. Originally known for her no-bake cheesecakes, fun mix-ins and crumbles, The Cheesecake Lady also makes baked cheesecakes, cookie sandwiches, cake slices and more — all with amazing flavor combinations. 

Cheesecake Cups

One of the highlights of The Cheesecake Lady’s menu is her cheesecake cups. The Strawberry Crunch cheesecake is a customer favorite, but you’ll also find classics like cherry, banana pudding, cookies and cream, peach cobbler and peanut butter brownie. Cheesecake cups come in 4-ounce, 6-ounce, 12-ounce or 16-ounce cups, with prices ranging from $5.50 to $13.50. The one-pound cheesecake cup is definitely a treat-yourself deal, but one that you won’t regret!

Related Page: Little Foodies – Local Kid Favorites 

Classic Cheesecakes

If you’re more into classic cheesecakes, The Cheesecake Lady accepts pre-orders for full cheesecakes. If you can’t decide which flavor of cheesecake to order, the perfect solution is the 13×9 cheesecake, which you can order in up to four flavors. This allows you to sample a variety of her creations and find your personal favorites.

The Cheesecake Lady

How to Get Your Cheesecake Fix

You’ll find The Cheesecake Lady’s cozy cheesecake store in the Butler-Tarkington neighborhood of Indianapolis, just south of Butler University. You can also order your desserts through Doordash. One thing to keep in mind: The menu options rotate daily, and due to the popularity of their limited items, they can sell out fast.

The Cheesecake Lady is open Tuesday to Saturday from 12-6 p.m., and closed on Sundays and Mondays. To find out which flavors The Cheesecake Lady will be offering, check her social media pages or visit

Related Articles



april 2024 Indys child magazine

From our Sponsors