Annie at Beef & Boards

“The sun’ll come out tomorrow.”

Could there be a more perfect start to a song?

The sweet optimism of little orphan Annie (who has every right to be jaded and cynical but somehow remains full of sunshine) is as irresistible to me today as it was when I first watched the movie and musical as a child. The latest production of Annie at Beef & Boards Dinner Theatre, on stage through July 15, left my little group of fans smiling and believing that “tomorrow, there’ll be sun.”

There are too many lovable moments to list, but here are my top five:

1. A Rock Star Redhead

Annie is a TOUGH role for any performer, and 12-year-old Claire Kauffman absolutely owned it. Her pure, solid voice made the tough high notes sound effortless, and I was impressed with her acting and character choices, especially the way she connected with Daddy Warbucks. Claire just completed fifth grade at Zionsville Middle School. On our way out of the theatre, I congratulated this little star on an amazing performance in what is certain to be a LONG theatre career!

Annie At Beef and Boards

2. A Dream Cast

Kudos to Beef & Boards for pulling together a dream team cast of veterans for this production. Nearly everyone on stage has been in shows here for decades, and their cumulative talent and professionalism makes the show sizzle. Ty Stover brought tears to my eyes with his portrayal of Oliver Warbucks. (My 8-year-old daughter said his big sentimental song, “Something Was Missing,” was her favorite Daddy Warbucks moment in the show, and I have to agree – he got me right in the heart!) This is the fourth consecutive time Ty has played this role at Beef & Boards. Just like last time, I was stunned by his strong, beautiful voice, his nuanced acting and his ability to make an arrogant billionaire lovable. Returning from the 2009 production to reprise their roles were Bobbi Bates as Grace Farrell, Jeff Stockberger as Rooster, and John Vessels as Drake. Kelly Teal Goyette, most recently seen as Mrs. Santiago in Ghost, the Musical, and Dragon in Shrek, the Musical, lent her impressive pipes to the role of Miss Hannigan, and my insanely talented amiga Deb Wims returned to Indianapolis to play Lily St. Regis. (Congrats, Deb, on earning the title of my VERY favorite “dumb hotel.”)

3. Drake, the Butler

Even if you don’t like cute orphans or musicals, I say you should still go see this show just to appreciate the comedic timing of John Vessels. Seriously. My family absolutely couldn’t get enough. Johnny V., I love how much you add to every single role you take on! (Have I said that too many times by now?) Seeing Drake the stuffy butler burst into one shockingly delighted high skip, then resuming his deadpan serious strut one second later, was just unforgettable. (In fact, I know a certain little girl who kept trying to imitate it during breakfast today…the sincerest form of flattery!)

4. A Tiny Orphan with BIG Personality

I could not take my eyes off little Sylvie Templet as Molly, the youngest orphan. I’ve known Sylvie since she was tiny. Sylvie has basically grown up at the theatre since her mom, talented pianist Kristy Templet, is part of the Beef & Boards orchestra. This was Sylvie’s Beef & Boards debut, and she could not have been cuter with her pigtails, glasses and attitude! She got a ton of laughs and looked like she was having the time of her life. I know what a dream it is for a kid to get their first big role. I can’t wait to see what’s next for her!

Annie At Beef and Boards

5. White House Magic

The iconic song “Tomorrow” is incredibly powerful when Annie belts it out on stage with her adorable dog, Sandy, but even more so when she joins FDR and his cabinet members in the White House for a reprise. Their strong voices locking into harmony gave me chills. More than anything, what got to me is the idea of a little girl using her voice to inspire discouraged government officials to dream bigger and persevere through difficult times. (Come to think of it,  can we send Annie to D.C. and just see what happens?)

Whatever is clouding your life at the moment, there’s a good chance that when that “sun comes out” on stage, your worries will melt away for a few hours. Congrats to the cast on a show worthy of many tomorrows!

Beef & Boards presents Annie as its 2018 Family Show, offering $10 discounts off tickets for all children ages 3-15. Tickets also include Chef Odell Ward’s family-friendly dinner buffet. For reservations, call the box office at 317.872.9664. For complete show schedule, visit


[activecampaign form=9]

Indy's Child
Indy's Child
For 40 years, Indy's Child has been the trusted source for Indianapolis families seeking fun, educational, and enriching experiences. Our award-winning magazine and website are dedicated to providing expert advice, insider tips, and up-to-date information on everything from the best local attractions and events to parenting resources and support. As local experts deeply rooted in the central Indiana community, our passionate team at Indy's Child is dedicated to uncovering the best family-friendly experiences and resources our city has to offer. Whether you're new to parenting or looking for new ideas, Indy's Child is here to help you enjoy the adventure of raising a family in central Indiana.

Related Articles



From our Sponsors