It’s Always Peanut Butter Jelly Time at Indy’s PB & J Factory

Peanut butter and jelly: It’s not just for kids! That is the vibe you get when you step up to the counter at PB & J Factory. Located inside The AMP — an artisan marketplace and food hall in the heart of 16 Tech — PB & J Factory offers sandwich combinations that appeal to kids … and kids at heart.


Breads and Spreads

PB & J Factory offers sweet and savory sandwiches in clever and comforting combinations. On the menu, you’ll find lots of options to customize your pb&j sandwich in almost any way you like. 

First, choose from three different types of bread: Texas toast, sourdough or whole wheat.

Second, pick your spread. On the menu, you’ll find the classic peanut butter, but also almond butter, cookie butter, marshmallow fluff, Reece’s spread and Nutella.

Third, pick your jam. Offerings include grape jelly, strawberry jam, apricot jam, raspberry jam, apple butter and bacon jam.

Lastly, pick a topping. Each sandwich includes one topping selection, and extra toppings are $1 each. Sandwich toppings include foods like strawberries, dill pickles, strawberry shortcake crumbles, Reece’s Crunch, cinnamon streusel, raisins and more. 

For those who find too many options to be overwhelming, PB & J Factory has a menu of specialty sandwiches for you to choose from. The Elvis pays homage to the king of rock n’ roll with peanut butter, bananas and chocolate syrup. The Jay-Z keeps it classic with peanut butter, grape jelly and honey. The Chuck Berry is a sweet treat with peanut butter, strawberry jam, mixed berry and chocolate syrup. And the Fluffer Nutter is an American classic: peanut butter, bananas, marshmallow fluff and chocolate syrup on thick Texas toast.

PB & J Factory

Why It’s Great for Families

PB & J Factory is a great place to satisfy the whims of children who have very specific ideas about what a great pb&j sandwich should include. Kids and parents both can get the exact sandwich they want, because customizing is welcome and encouraged here. 

But also: PB & J Factory is a great place to visit if you want a sweet treat that’s both comforting and familiar. You can take the classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich up a notch with toppings and syrups, and create a dessert that’s as unique as you are.

Where It’s Located + Hours

PB & J Factory is located inside The AMP, a marketplace and food hall at 16 Tech. Located just north of IUPUI, PB & J Factory is at 1220 Waterway Blvd. in Indianapolis. PB & J Factory is open Wednesday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. You can find them on their Facebook page at


Nicole Sipe
Nicole Sipe
Nicole Sipe is the editor of Indy's Child and Southwest Ohio Parent magazines. She has a BA in Journalism from California State University Northridge, and has been involved in the print and digital publishing world for most of her life. Born and raised in Southern California, Nicole traded the city and sun for corn and creeks, and now lives in central Indiana with her husband, two sons and Collie. Her latest book for children, “All About Me! Art Journal” was published in 2022 by Walter Foster Jr. In her spare time, she likes traveling with her family, enjoying good food and drink, volunteering at her children’s schools and around her community, and practicing yoga.

Related Articles



From our Sponsors