Indianapolis, and its surrounding areas are known for a wide variety of iconic eats that reflect the region’s rich culinary traditions. Whether you’re craving classic Midwestern comfort food or something with a bit more flair, here are some of the top iconic dishes and eateries in the Indy area that you must try:
1. The “Indiana” Tenderloin Sandwich at The Mug
Known for its hefty pork tenderloin sandwiches, The Mug is a local staple serving up a version of the Indiana classic that draws crowds from all over the state. The breaded and fried tenderloin is piled high, offering a hearty meal that defines local comfort food.
Address: 17 N. College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
2. Indiana-Style Pork Chop
Indiana is known for its high-quality pork, and the Indiana-style pork chop is a regional favorite. Typically, the pork chop is grilled or pan-seared and served with mashed potatoes and other hearty sides. The Rathskeller, a German restaurant located in downtown Indianapolis, is a great spot to sample this dish, often paired with sauerkraut or a German-style beer.
Address: 401 E Michigan St, Indianapolis, IN
3. Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie
A beloved dessert in Indiana, sugar cream pie is a rich, custard-like dessert made with a simple filling of cream, sugar, butter, and vanilla. It’s a regional classic that is often served at family gatherings or local diners. For the best slice in Indianapolis, head to Pots & Pans Pie Co., which specializes in various pies, including this sweet Hoosier favorite.
Address: 4915 N. College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
4. Dutch Baby at Milktooth
Milktooth, located in Fountain Square, is famous for its creative brunch offerings. Among its iconic dishes is the Dutch baby pancake, a puffy pastry sometimes made savory (like the BLT version) and other times delivered sweet (such as the peach melba variety with raspberry creme fraiche).
Address: 534 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
5. Indiana “Hoosier” Chili
Chili is a beloved dish in the Midwest, and Indiana has its own style. Indiana chili tends to be a bit thicker and heartier, often featuring beef, pork, beans, and a combination of spices. Nick’s Chili Parlor has been doing one-of-a kind flavor since 1974 when founder Nick Ferris and his father Jim, began serving the “Not yet World Famous” 5-Way Chili, giant breaded tenderloins and chili dogs.
Address: 719 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
6. Hand-Cut Fries at The Steer-In
The Steer-In is an Indianapolis classic, serving up fresh, hand-cut fries that have become a local favorite. While their menu is packed with other comfort food favorites, these fries, with their crispy exterior and soft interior, are a standout and perfect to pair with any sandwich or entrée.
Address: 5102 W 10th St, Indianapolis, IN
7. Shapiro’s Classic Reuben
Shapiro’s Delicatessen has been a staple in Indianapolis since 1905, when the family first opened a grocery and deli just south of downtown. Over the years, they’ve honed their craft, especially with their sandwiches, which are stacked with flavorful meats between slices of fresh, housemade bread. The Reuben, in particular, has become a fan favorite, featuring a hearty serving of corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing, all piled on rye bread.
Address: 808 S. Meridian St. Indianapolis, IN
8. Shrimp Cocktail at St. Elmo Steak House
St. Elmo Steak House is an Indianapolis landmark, and their famous shrimp cocktail is legendary. The shrimp are served chilled, and the cocktail sauce is loaded with horseradish, providing a spicy kick. It’s one of the most iconic appetizers in the city and has been a staple of the St. Elmo menu for over a century. The restaurant itself is a classic, offering steaks and seafood in a historic, upscale setting.
Address: 127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN
9. Long’s Bakery’s Famous Glazed Yeast Donut
For decades, this classic Indianapolis bakery has been the city’s top spot for doughnuts. You might encounter a line (getting there early is a smart move), but that just gives you more time to admire the mouthwatering pastries in the display case at Long’s Bakery. A great choice is the glazed yeast doughnut, which practically melts in your mouth
Address: 1453 N Tremont St, Indianapolis, IN & 2301 E Southport Rd, Indianapolis, IN
10. Indiana Craft Beer
While not technically a food, Indiana’s craft beer scene is a key part of the state’s food culture. Sun King Brewery and Three Floyds Brewing are two of the most iconic breweries in the area. Pair a cold, locally brewed beer with your meal at any of the area’s great restaurants for the complete Indiana experience.
